After seeing this thread, and a post from Brunswick on facebook (to which I asked some questions), I think I'm going to go with these shoes to replace my Tanks. Honestly, they look like a more comfortable version of the Tanks. My concern is what size.
How snug is snug? My Tanks were really tight when I got them, especially one shoe. I had to snip the bands inside the shoe. Over time, they now comfortably fit. Brunswick replied to my post saying that they are soft up top and will break in well. I normally wear a 12 4E shoe. Most 12 wide sport shoes fit me, but some are tighter than others. The half size cut off always seems to be 11.5, and that seems to be the case here.
So the debate is 12 wide, 13 normal, or 13 wide (probably too big, but who knows). If they made 12.5 wide, I'd definitely go with those.