Well, stop eating all that fried chicken just before league!!
Just kidding. I also tried that Benzoin Tincture compound a few years back. It's used in medicine to help make bandages stick better, among other things. It does work but is kind of messy.I used it with the roll thumb tape but found I didn't need it when I went to individual piece of tape.
I got mine in a supermarket (Pathmark) pharmacy. They had to order it but it was cheap. I don't remember the exact price. Still got the remainder of the silly bottle.
FYI It's 80% alcohol so 90% of the efficacy of it is probably due to the alcohol, but that's not a medical opinion. (no smiley face)
You might also try using some 91% alcohol to clean the surface of your thumb just before applying the thumb tape. (Do NOT use acetone!!!)
"None are so blind as those who will not see."
"A comedian says funny things. A comic says things funny."