Try cleaning your finger with a alcohol patch before you apply the hada patch. It will hold till the cows come home.

Does anyone know if there is VISE tape, in a roll, that is similar in feel to the VISE Hada Patch (blue) pre-cut tape?  Love the feel of these pre-cut strips, but they start to peel on me after a game.

They HAD rolls of Hada Patch before they had the strips. For me the pre-cut strips  stuck to my skin MUCH, MUCH better than pieces cut from the roll. So much so that I gave up completely on the rolls and have only used the strips for the past 8 - 10 years. I still have the last remnants of that roll, sitting unused.

Given the force with which I need to use to remove Hada patch strips from my thumb, I'd strongly suggest that either something is seriously wrong with the strips you have or something is very wrong with the skin on your thumb.

Make sure the strips are not too old to be used and clean your thumb with alcohol before applying the strip OR use Benzoin tincture to coat that area before applying the strip. Benzoin tincture can be attained from almost any decent pharmacy.
 

I use the rolls and don't have much issue with them not sticking. For best results, I make sure to wash/dry my hands first, but even without, I usually don't have a problem. No alcohol required. Turbo tape does not work as well for me though. I use two pieces to cover more of my thumb, so the rolls suit me better.