From your description I would recommend something at entry level reactive resin, such as the Ebonite Tornado, Brunswick Power Groove, etc., or no more than one level above entry level. One ball I've read a lot of good things about (haven't drilled one yet, though) is the Columbia Freeze. Bowlingball.com has them for $85 delivered. And yes, nicks and scratches are normal wear and tear on a ball. You can help keep the ball looking good and performing well by wiping it before each shot, cleaning it after every bowling session with a good cleaner, and having the oil extracted on a regular basis, every 100 games or so. -- JohnP