if your thumb swells then making the hole tighter won't help
tape makes the hole tighter.
take your ball in and have them open up your thumbhole, and then adjust it out w/ tape
Also there are products like Magic Carpet you put in the back of the hole that help you get a snug fit, that don't change your span
I would not suggest putting tape on your digit, jmo
--------------------
I'm your huckleberry