I have heard good things about both these balls but I have also heard they both can be really condition specific.  I was hoping to get one of these balls to fill my medium to medium to dry conditions.  I am a high tracker, with more revs than speed.  Pap is 5 1/2 over and 1 up.  If you guys where to chose one which ball would u pick to fit this slot.

Yeah, the Smokin needs a little extra time to rev up.  Matches up great for me, but you can't get firm with it, you'll leave flat stuff all day.  Now, it's a little more consistent roll than the Punisher, but definitely too much hook for what you're looking for.
--------------------
New member of the Metal Militia!!!  If you think Simple Plan is metal, then you must die.  And not get to be a member . .\m/!!!