Well they are both excellent balls, but are very far apart. I bought 5 of the Scorchin 2nds and 3 of the WP Smokins. The scorchin is a beast and is not JUST a hook monster. It NEEDS oil to work properly. The WP Smokin is one of my favorite balls right now. I did not like the original red pin smokin that much, but the WP version seems to give a longer and smoother but hard arc reaction. It will be usable on more THS than the Scorchin. Like I said, they are both excellent balls but both are very far apart. If this will be your only ball, I would pass on both and get something else for medium that will be playable on a wider variety of shots. If you already have a medium oiler, then yes..give either of these a try.
--------------------
****Kids in the back seat cause accidents; accidents in the back seat cause kids.****
Edited on 1/21/2007 11:05 AM