Since you already have the Agent Orange, I'd suggest you go with the Noize. Despite what the other fellers say about the Noise being a lot weaker than the Resurgence, it really isn't. As you probably know, at least 80% of a ball's reaction is attributable to its coverstock. As the Noize has the same coverstock as the Resurgence, it's going to handle oil also.
I think you'll find that the Noise will be a nice option when your Agent Orange is starting to burn up, as you'll be able to move out and play a little more down and in with the Noize.
The Noize is also cheaper than the Resurgence.