I bought an Icon 300 used, plugged, resurfaced, etc. five months ago, had it drilled, and put about 20-25 games on it... (The previous owner had used it for a grand total of 2 games)
I have left it pretty much at 800 grit Scotch Brite for a while now, but I get virtually no hook out of it... I did bake/sweat/soak it for a bit today and oil poured out, but I didn't go on for too long seeing as it's such a controversial practice and all...
It's to the point that I may polish it and see if it will snap on medium, broken down league shot...
Anyone who has the Icon 300 care to share their surface, conditions it encounters and/or reaction?