Well, I only work with Brunswick's HG an RB since it is the only stuff available around here. About RB, I second CharlesT - it depends really on the base grit you apply. Do not get too fine, I found anytghing less than 600 grit to be counterproductive - at least on my home-made spinner and my style.
HG has no grit, whatsoever, and works well with any coverstock I tried it on, including Columbia, Brunswick (incl. MoRich, Revolution), Storm, Hammer. Especially Storm covers seem to respond well to HG.
I just found that whan I use 400 base grit as recommended by Brunswick, the finish is not very even. You see and feel the sanding lines, which is still the case on a 1.000 grit base (grey pad). Again, this can the result of my non-standard spinner.
I also found that these "rough" polished surfaces did not work well for me on the lanes. But with a base of 1.500 grit (sanding pad) or less, the surface becomes almost mirror-like and the balls read the lane very well, so this is the finish I normally apply, or a 2.000 grit Abralon base + HG.
HG works well with a fine base grit, while RB does not. In so far, these complement each other well.
HG will leave definititvely a slicker surface than pure 4.000 Abralon. The Abralon surface will read the lane better, earlier (from personal tests, I'd say 3-5' on the same ball), and with a base grit of 1.000 or more, you have more sanding lines in the surface than 4.000 or even 2.000 Abralon. I think a 400 base + HG comes close to 2.000 Abralon, in overall reaction, but the finer teh base, the more skid/snap a HG application will IMHO yield on a ball.
Your Toxic might have been too coarse at 320 grit. I had a similar effect on my Reaction Rip and Sahara with just a 800 base + HG: no control, poor hook, I thought the balls were dead. Then I tried the 2.000 Abralon base + HG, et voilà , both balls became those famous sharp hookers again I had known them before the 800 grit base treatment. Really strange how much slight adjustments can change overall ball performance. My tip: try a finer grit on the Toxic, and see what happens?
--------------------
DizzyFugu - Reporting from Germany
Confused by bowling?
Check out BR.com's vault of wisdom: the unofficial FAQ section