The original surface of depth charge is 1500grit polished. It can be reached by using Storm Step1 and Step 2 after sanding with 320 grit sand paper.
However, I experienced similar things after I tried to resurface mine.
(I did it after about 150 games)
Whatevet you do, do not use high gloss if you would like to have the original surface back.
Burgundy pad and non grit polish (like Track Magic Shine) will do close. Still a bit more lenght. (I did 6 sides, all 30secs)
Green pad and 600 grit polish worked well also, but smoother and a bit less backend.
Hope this helps,
Burak