Sounds like you never rinsed it off with a wet paper towel, and probably just wiped it off instead. A bowling "friend" of mine used to do this very thing and had the same result, and then would complain about his ball the next time he bowled. I was going to tell him he was doing it wrong, but he was a know it all, so I let it pass......
Btw, I use enough to spread it all around the ball using a paper towel, wiping firmly for around 20 seconds or so, then I let it sit on the ball for 1 minute. After that, I thoroughly wet a new paper towel, wipe the ball off with it, rinse and repeat until all of the CnD is gone. Then I usually do a quick final clean with Remedy Rx. Ball is always clean and tacky feeling afterwards. Works for me.