It would have had to have been a "perfect mistake", if you will, to have a span that short to begin with and it fix itself just by a pitch change. Not saying it isn't possible though...
My hand is I guess normal size whatever that is... and my pitches are 0 all the way around except pitching out the fingers so they don't run together. However, it took me a whole year to find pitches and a span that was comfortable. It's not a fun trip trying to find a grip that feels (and works) best, trust me on that one.
If I understand correctly as to where your thumb is snagging, it does still sound like a little shorter span would help. With a streched span, your thumb actually drags against the back of the hole towards the release because at that point, the tip of the thumb is geometrically further away from your fingers at the release rather than fully in the ball. Your fingers are the pivot point to a release (since your thumb comes out first, then fingers). Therefore, it is only at the maximum strech position (max distance from the pivot point. ie: thumb nearly out of the ball) that you can tell if your span is too long, although if it's a pain just to get/keep your thumb in then thats obvious to alot of people.
If we are talking about the left side of the thumb as you put your hand out in front of you and give a thumbs up, then this makes sense. Due to being a righty, the "left" part of the thumb is pointed away from the fingers in the grip, so this would see the most friction in a streched span
Before typing this, I pulled out a ball that I can't throw anymore cause I hang up in this ball (was a ball that I hadn't changed the span to 1/4th shorter) and experienced a snag similar to what you said is happening to you, assuming still taking about the same side of the fingernail. So with too long of a span, I felt the same thing.
These are my thoughts but if your ball driller is trustworthy and knows your game, he's really the best to talk to since I'm only able to "imagine" whats really going on.
Any other questions just let me know.
By the way, I'm NOT a ball driller or fitter. I'm just a person that knows a good fit when I feel it
--------------------
Brunswick Advisory Staff
Jared Wolf
Jonesboro, AR
www.bowlingchat.netThe opinions expressed are solely those of the writer and not of Brunswick Corporation.