I know it's been a while since I first posted, but I just wanted to update.
I finally went in to see Jonathan about a new ball a few weeks ago. He's actually got another shop in the Bowlero in Williamsburg now, which is great because I'm a good bit closer to that one. I think he travels back and forth between both shops. Anyway he is AMAZING, very knowledgeable! He gave me a great deal on a ball and it feels great!
I just got to bowl my first real game with it yesterday and bowled 211. And that was after I messed up the first 2 frames badly lol.
Johnny D, thanks for hooking me up with Jonathan!