I have to agree with JustRico I had similar problems as you described and when all was said & done, I found a new pro shop driller who shortened my span and actually changed my thumb pitch from from 1/8th reverse to 1/8th forward pitch. This change has greatly improved my release and game. The span change wasn't drastically shorter, but it made a big difference as I got the proper relaxed fingertip grip and I don't subconsciously squeeze my grip like I did before. Bottom line, it has helped to free up my armswing and increased my speed & rev rate. My old span and reverse thumb pitch caused me to have problems exiting the thumbhole cleanly and my release was definitely inconsistent. If you have another pro shop driller in your area with a good reputation, I'd definitely recommend that you discuss the problems you're having clearing the thumbhole and then have your span re-checked.