I like mine just a hair loose but then again, my fingers don't really swell much. But it's all about preference.
Glad to hear you tried it out. You know what they say, "once you go grips you never go back"......Uh, maybe not. But still. I went no grips last fall and never looked back. SO much better for me. Cleaner release (my fingers hung too much with any kind of grips) which means more revs. Plus, one thing about no grips, is that you can actually feel the pitch of your finger holes, so it's important you get those right.
--------------------
- Andy
Brunswick...........'nuff said.