BrunsRich,
I'll let you answer that question seperately regarding that interpertation, but your thought provoking comments have me thinking.
Recently I have been involved in a little funny experiment for myself.
My best bowling came with an extremely stretched span of 4 15/16. Stretched very hard my last joint got a tad over the lip of my finger inserts. During this time I had a definitive feeling of thumb out..... a long period of time and then a distintive feeling of lift from my fingers without doing any lifting, just firm. As I used to tell people. Boom......LAG.....Boom!
My ball had a distinctive and heavy roll! Similar to guys that I occasionally see with true spans in the 5 1/2 inch range. Heavy roll...big time seperation between thumb finger.
Thumb damage with this setup was the inevitable result and I had it!
I loved the roll.
Since that time I have been trying to get to a comfortable place where I could get that roll and not damage my thumb. Most of the adjustments I have made have placed my span shorter where the last joint is past the middle of the hole with moderate stretch. Say 4 11/16. This has been....well not so good.
Dropping...lack of seperation. Discomfort relative to stretched.
At the same time I have observed on the protour the distinctive early thumb long span of such guys as Mika and Walter Ray with their big hands heavy roll styles. And also the shorter span high rev style of say Chris Barnes(who looks like sometimes he is fighting the ball from getting down too quickly in to the lane. This style has definitively less seperation in thumb finger release time than the Walter Ray style. And as you stated their is almost a tie in the times for release.
So then 3 weeks ago or so I attend a trade show and know it Mo is there.
Ball designer...layout and grip king. He takes and shortens me another notch and puts me at 4 1/2. Also with a powerlift we end up with 1/4 forward on my ring for the pilot hole. Whether it is the forward...or it is the shortness of grip. Last finger joint is touching back of insert(I call this a semi fingertip). I am revvin the ball for me like Robert Smith(say 360 rpms from 280). No dropping, tons of revs and almost heavy roll like before. Surprisingly I have not had to go to more forward with the thumb! Most surprising is the feeling of very little seperation between thumb and finger release.
Now while 4 9/16 feels cramped, this 4 and 1/2(or maybe 4 15/32) does not.
Whether it is the forward in the ring finger that is keeping the ball on my hand much longer and preventing dropping or just that the middle ground of span lengths for me is no good. This semi fingertip is exciting me!
For whatever reason the ball all of a sudden feels like I am developing a long flat spot in my swing with this grip versus what has always been titled a fairly steep downswing. Since I switched from my super stretched span.
As I just stumbled upon this recently I have not completed the testing to see if forward in the ring (I do Not have more flexibility in this finger versus my middle) is what is causing the difference and if that would make the more traditional relaxed fingertip spans workable or if the new answer for me is this distinctively semifingertip grip.
I found your comments interesting in light of this development and wonder if you could add anything regarding what I am finding?
REgards,
Luckylefty