JohnP-
Thank you for taking the time to respond. I went to the shop today and talked to the owner about the problem. He immediately wanted to go more right, but I was hesitant. So to humor me he reslugged a ball with 0 lateral and 1/4 reverse, which is the amount of reverse I have always used; not the 1/8 I posted earlier. Anyhow, I threw the new ball 2 shots and told him it was quite a bit worse. We went back into the shop and went to 5/16 right and kept the 1/4 reverse. This ball was much better, but by this time my thumb was so tender that anything was bothering it. I am going to let it heal and throw the ball with the new pitches and see what happens. I might have to go a little more yet, but it feels like we're on the right track. Thanks again for the response, it is much appreciated.
Don