I have tried both ways, white tape under thumb and black tape under and for me, have found the black under and white back side works the best. I do like the quicker exit the black tape offers but needed the 'space' taken up by the white.
I have a wide thumb and no matter how I work the hole, I do need the tape to have a good fit. I have not found the tape to make that much difference in pitch, unless you are using more than two or you use the Ebonite tape doubled as it's thicker than pro grip tape. But, it is a personal thing and as long as it works for you, then you've found the answer.
Keep in mind, what works for one will/might not work for another. As long as you exit as you wish, the feel to you is comfortable, then there you have it.
Happy Bowling.
--------------------
az guy aka: R & L Bowlers Pro
rlbowlerspro@cox.net
www.rlbowlerspro.comLooking for treasures ? Take a look at my wife's ebay store
http://www.ebaystores.com/Pitas-Place?refid=store