Isn't that ball discontinued? Unless you are getting a really good deal on it, I would think you might want to try something that doesn't have so many mixed reviews. I mean its pretty much the same with any ball - you have a 50/50 shot that it will work for you, but you would be going into already knowing that so many people think the ball doesn't live up to its hype.
I would think maybe something from the Xcel line, or maybe something from Hammer. Can't really give you much advice because I use my Nemesis for pretty much every condition (but I have it drilled 2E for a smooth, early arc), and my style seems to match up better with the mid-priced symmetric balls for some reason.