Quick update on this to put any questions to rest. I fired an email last night to Buddies and planned to call them this morning. Turns out I didn't need to call at all, when I got up I had a reply to my email from Chad at Buddies that a new ball was being sent out. No trouble, no questions, no hassle, just top notch customer service.
The only bad thing in this experience is that I won't be using my new Sauce in leagues this week. Good thing is that I have a nice paper weight until I figure out what to do with the beat up ball. hehe