I'm seeing the same thing here. I think I actually need the cover to die a little. Out of the box I hated it. Did exactly what the original poster stated. After a game it seemed to get better and I shot 250 with it. Cleaned it and first game out of the bag was the same thing, rolling out and no recovery. The next game was 268. I don't know if it is just getting used to the roll, but it definitely seems to work better after it gets some oil into it. I'm going to take it to 4000 and polish and see what it does. I wanted a strong pearl, because all my other pearls were just too long, but this cover might be too strong for me when teh cover is fresh.