SK, you're ball was not rolling out. Because when you sand the ball, it should roll out sooner/more. With the pin over the fingers, you were probably getting too much length to where the ball was wishy washy on the carrydown, looking like rollout.
I would adjust your sanding to a higher grit or polish the ball to a lower grit. The CG out layout gives the ball a smoother reaction on the backend, which may be adding to your problem. =:^D