Bowlers with higher ball speeds should (generally ) stay away from "polish" until they have tried smoother and smoother grit finishes, all the way up to the finest grit finish available. If then they find they still need more, polish becomes a viable finish.
My suggestion would be to take the surface back down to the original surface, then try smoother and smoother grits WITHOUT polish until you gain the reaction level that you are looking for.
If you get all the way to 4000 abralon finish and still need something less, then go back to the factory finish and add polish over that. Continue the above process WITH polish until you get the reaction level you are looking for.
Whatever you did to it was too much. You should be able to use the difference from the original finish and the current finish to slightly gauge what need to be done next. We already know factory finish is too much hook, and current finish is too little hook, so split the difference and try that.
--------------------
Norm Duke was right Good transactions list in my profile
My Bowl.com member page