The vinyl slugs are usually very smooth. It can create suction, especially if it's a little snug or fits well. The urethane slugs allow your thumb to breathe just a little more, I believe, but I don't know that the difference is really noticeable unless the thumbhole is sanded with some rough sandpaper to allow more air in and out.
--------------------
The weekly signature series, by Hamster, presenting a mini-series of quotes from the Blue Collar Comedy tour!
"Fishin reminds me of a girl I was with, we went down to the lake down 'ere. She wanted to make love on a horse, and I'd never done it, so we did it, and I'm trying to keep my balance, and she's fallin' off, then the manager at the Wal-Mart came out and unplugged 'er there. I didn't even want to make love on the horse, I wanted to do it on the rocket ship . ."