Txbowler,
I understand what you said. But in our league we do it by draft. And the positions are set based on averages. So if we had 9 teams as we did this year, the lowest average on the team bowls leadoff, the middle average middle, and the highest average last. Since we draft based on average, the leadoffs are usually the lowest 9 averages in the league. Now at any given time, someone may start improving, or match up to a pattern better and move from leadoff to second or the opposite. So with that in mind, you are bowling against others at your skill level on the tougher patterns. So a "decent" bowler will be bowling against other "decent" bowlers, for the most part. So unless they improve, they won't be bowling against the "true" good bowlers.
I understand the thinking though. But what I don't understand is why people think this way. Why wouldn't you want to better your skills by bowling in a Sports league? If you want to "win" more on your THS leagues, then this is a way to do it. It will also help you improve if you go to tournaments. Now, I do realize there is a certain population of bowlers that will never bowl in a sports shot league. I am not trying to convert them as I know that is impossible. What I am looking for is the next level up from that, the 180-210 average THS bowlers. I know there is no easy answers, but anything anyone has tried that has worked, I'd be willing to listen to. Thanks for taking the time to reply.