Jac,
Your idea sounds alright, though I do echo some of your concerns about finishing time and the like. In my area we have a scratch match-play league similar to what you're talking about. Last year it was 1-on-1, but there are more guys this year, so now you bowl 2 matches at the same time. Three players per pair, each bowling the other two. It's broken into 3 trimesters for the season. The 1st and 2nd place finishers of each trimester qualify for the playoffs, and there are wildcard spots that go to those with the best W-L records among non-winners. It's a cool league. Because of the start time, we only bowl on the second shift house shot, so that kind of sucks. It's still a lot of fun. In the summer we have scratch-match play league that rotates through the different PBA patterns. People seemed to like that one. You have a lot of freedom with this. I would prospect some of the guys you think might be interested to see what they have to say about the whole thing. Good luck to you.
--------------------
Bowling is without a doubt the dumbest, most pointless, most idiotic excuse for a game that has ever been invented. So, what time are we bowling tomorrow?