He probably DOESN'T care if its been a failure or not because, irrespective of either its success or failure, we are wherewe are today. That's what Sunshine deals with, absolutes.
I, in no way, am trying to put words in his mouth, but I've dealt with him before. He often makes good points, but infuses them within a context that can raise ones temperature past the boiling point, especially if one only concentrates on the presentation.
Mighty Fish, your story and mine aren't all that different, except for the part about having to quit, and that may be short lived. Earlier this year, I shattered my elbow and upper arm on my bowling arm, and haven't gotten to the point that I can even try again. I may be out of bowling as well.
That doesn't keep us from both CARING, and SPECULATING, about what has happened to the sport/game and where its going, if anywhere.
Perhaps he's(Sunshine) right, maybe bowling HAS passed both you and me by. In that case, our remarks are little more that fodder with which to charge the cannon's of opinion with, and more than ever before, I am beginning to believe that to be the case.
Make no mistake, that won't stop me from caring, or having an opinion, but it will help me to understand that the opinions I do have are less and less relevant with each day that passes.