Bigmike, I stand corrected if the Orange Dot was a soft rubber ball. All I know is that those of use who used the Orange Dot got rid of it real fast.
Interestingly, I bought a Black U-Dot with a dull cover in late 1990 just before I moved from South Florida to Richmond, Va. I remember having it drilled stacked positive layout, but I didn't use it for a few years. When I did use it, the ball didn't do anything for me -- it was as if it was merely a spare ball -- and I went on to buy a Blue Hammer and Burgundy Hammer, which I still own and use. I suppose the Black U-Dot was great on wood lanes and during the short-lived short oil era.
I also had during that short-oil era a Wine U-Dot, which I liked, but pin carry was an issue once moving inside the 10-board; that was solved when I copped a Brunswick Whine Rhino from a prominent touring pro. If you recall the Pearl Gold Dot, that was my go-to ball, not so much for scoring but for accuracy and consistency. It's also my only artifact from the 1980s.