You have two options for getting the same feel from ball to ball. One is interchangeable thumb inserts. The other is getting a slug made from a mold of the thumbhole that does feel good. The reason I use interchangeable thumbs is because my thumb changes sizes pretty drastically depending on the time of day, so it's much easier and more consistent than adding and removing large quantities of tape all the time. I can have a looser thumbhole for mornings and a tighter thumbhole for nights.
I'm not familiar with Grip Loc, but I used to have Switch Grips. They were pretty good, but I had issues with some outer sleeves being much tighter than others (making it nearly impossible to get the insert out of the ball sometimes) and had a couple break on me.
I recently started installing Vise's new IT interchangeable thumb, but have only had them for about a week now and my ball driller and I are just now perfecting the installation process. (We had to lower his drill press slightly to accomodate the hole for the molly that gets inserted deep in the ball at the base of the thumb inserts) The system is very well-engineered though. They put a lot of thought into how to do it best. As I mentioned before, I'm going to post some pics of this when I get a chance. (Been too busy the past few days!)
And yes, it's a pain to switch thumb inserts regularly -- I do NOT use an interchangeable thumb on my spare ball. I'm not as worried about the feel on it being perfect, so that's fine for me.