I felt the same way. My strongest ball for league is a Hustle Ink, then a Super Natural, and the Ride. The Hustle Ink is just too much ball that I have to put it away during the first game. I just got a Black Widow Urethane, thinking that this way the answer to all my problems. Finally got it after waiting almost a month, and bowled with it for the first time in league. Needless to say that it didn't work out so well and had to go back to the Ride. The BW wasn't carrying no matter where I played and kept leaving single pins or splits.
Any suggestions for a surface change? It just has a very light coat of polish on it at the moment.