xrayjay,
I have used a plastic spare ball since the mid-1990's. And I have had the same ball since that time as well, the clear plastic Wolf. Yes, I have had small issues with some cracking around the thumb hole, but it's plastic, I just had it drilled out, plugged, and redrilled the exact same thumb hole. I have tried with/without a slug and now have a switch grip in it. I see a small bit of cracking out around the sleeve, but it is very minor.
Personally, I throw plastic at every spare....I go back and forth on it with double wood, if I am really on my spares I will throw the plastic at it, straight at the front pin, if I am not, I will roll my strike ball at it. I try to go straight at every spare on the left, taking the lane out of play, especially on longer, flatter sports patterns. I am not 100% on them, but I know my spare percentage went up when I went to plastic, and went up again went I went to throwing straight at left side spares with it. If you have a spare ball, what's the big deal with just getting it drilled out and plugged when it cracks. You can do it 2-3 times at least and be under what you would have paid for a new spare ball. With the Wolf, I love having the actual Wolf weight block in it, it becomes a monster on dry lanes, and my carry percentage is much higher than throwing a WD or something with just a pancake flip block. I like it so much I have a NIB one sitting in my closet just waiting for the first one to crack beyond repair. I thought I would be throwing the new one by now, but the old one just keeps going and going and going, lol.
Just my .02.