Uh, I am surprised to be listed as a benchmark writer (*bow*). Well, IMHO it is very important to be as specific as possible about the ball, its setup, the conditions you played it on and your style. This is hard to provide, since one might for instance only guess the conditions at hand.
I would not call your review "bad" - but it does not yield much reference for the readers to make a judgement about relative strength, performance etc.. Inverted 1 is correct about this, and this is IMHO constructive critics.
I also read the follow-up by lane1who when it appeared shortly afterwards, and I was not pleased by this "gesture", since I had the impression that you were writing about your personal experience with the ball. Do not take it personally. I guess it is someone else with a problem about your review
Bowl great!
--------------------
DizzyFugu - Reporting from Germany
Team X website & more about me
"Put some make-up on your face
Make this world a better place!"
Kahimi Karie, 'Good morning world'