I tried the blue one. Wasn't really fond of it for 2 reasons.
One, it was much thicker than all the other tapes I tried. If you're thumb was just a little loose, requiring too much pressure to hold onto the ball, one piece of other brands made the hole fit right. One piece of the blue and I couldn't get my thumb in the hole.
Two, you can't adjust it because there is so little glue on the back. Once you take it out, it never sticks to anything again.
I've used Master white thumb tape for 20 years now and never had one problem with it. Have tried Brunswick and Storm and they are not better, but equally good. None of them have had the glue "leak" through to the surface.