It was stated Barnes had brutal bowl reaction.........then how did he strike in the 7th,8th,& 9th? Hum!
When Barnes walked on the approach bent down & picked up his ball while wiping it was clear he was not confident. Then when he looked up he looked like a deer in headlights. (go back and review the tape, it's on you tube). It was then that I said to my buddies, he is going to choke.
You'all may have seen something different, but that is what I saw and you know what that's OK. We all see things differently.
But, I will not subscribe to a bad ball reaction for Barnes going into the 10th coming off a three bagger. If anyone all of a sudden had a bad ball reaction it was T.D.
As you stated, you have every right to form your own opinion of how things went down; however, I think that you're giving yourself a lot of credit for powers of intuition that may or may not be there. You just KNOW from seeing the way he picked up his ball what was going through his mind and how he'd react in that moment? I'm not sure I buy that. Yes, maybe you did get a feeling that he was uncomfortable before making that shot, and he clearly didn't make his best shot. Does that automatically mean it was a choke?
A lot of this comes down to one's definition of what it means to choke. I view the Barnes-Haugen match from a few years back as a choke. I view Mika, one of the Tour's best spare shooters, flagging a 10-pin to hand Norm a major as a choke. Barnes failing to come up with a big double on tough lanes when he'd barely found the pocket all game long doesn't necessarily equal a choke in my book.
To me, flagging a 10-pin is a choke for a pro. To me, missing the head-pin on a crucial shot (when you haven't missed it once before) is a choke for a pro. There are other examples, but I think you get the point. I think that a lot of people are quick to throw out the choke label anytime someone fails to perform. Not all losses = a choke in my book. There is a lot that goes into it for me to throw that label out there. Maybe you're different.