win a ball from Bowling.com

Author Topic: Restoring integrity  (Read 1135 times)

qstick777

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5188
Restoring integrity
« on: October 10, 2006, 10:58:58 AM »
Okay, this has been brought up time and time again, but I just wanted to start what I hope will be an interesting topic.

People have been saying for a while now that scoring has gotten out of hand and that bowling has lost a lot of it's integrity.  People have blamed it on the sanctioning body, the ball manufacturers, the lane operators, and many other reasons, and there have been many suggestions on how to restore integrity.

A big thing that always comes up is "oil."  There is always a big cry for more oil and eliminating the THS, wall, cakeshot, whatever you want to call it.  Obviously this can easily be changed by the USBC and the lane operators.  Most likely, the harder the conditions become the more the manufacturers will do to create stronger balls.

Then we always have people that blame it on the balls.  You know, the hook-in-a-box balls that we have these days.  Funny thing is, I don't see many people going back to using plastic with pancake blocks or even old-school urethane.  It seems that everybody wants to buy the latest and greatest hook-in-a-box!

A while back I seem to recall somebody mentioning something about making the pins heavier.  That really seems like a reasonable solution.  I remember watching a tournament on ESPN Classic and the announcer mentioned that the pins being used were heavier than normal pins.  I think they were the gold Brunswick pins, IIRC.  Heavier pins would be something that could easily be used.  I don't know how expensive that would be for the lane operators, but it also gives the option to make them only available to USBC sanctioned play.  So basically, you would have to practice on the lanes with lighter pins, but actual league play and tournaments would be held with the heavier pins.

What do you guys think needs to be done to restore integrity to bowling?
--------------------
Best post ever:http://www.ballreviews.com/Forum/Replies.asp?TopicID=74110&ForumID=16&CategoryID=5

Search Ballreviews entire database here: http://www.bowling-info.com/Search.html

 

BrianCRX90

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2486
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #1 on: October 10, 2006, 07:34:12 PM »
I think the pins should remain the same look and weight for USBC bowling. HOWEVER...I do think the PBA needs to use heavier pins. I think it's time for another step from the casual or serious USBC bowler either from a decent to bad to elite player from the professional. The PBA needs to make the pins from 4-5 or more pounds. They also need to be a different color then white. The reason being is to visibly show people that the pros are using a different pin then open play and USBC bowlers. Then use them for the entire tournament.Keep the under 3 pound or 2.8 pounds or whatever the standard pins everyone uses alone. If you increased the weight much more then really only the hard throwing crankers would be sucessful unless you put out some confined oil pattern every night. I've bowled with the 3lb 10 ounce gold pins when they were big in the late 90's and early 00's and combined with that and a sport shot it was obviously harder. Also, alot of machines especially A-2's do not like heavier pins. Alot of problems at my center were caused by those pins so you may need brand new machines that is capable of hauling around pins that are twice as heavy.

There are other modifications to decrease scoring like changing the material of the pindeck to a softer material and deeping the gutters. Other then making all the centers spend money just to make modifications there really isn't more you can do. It's not like golf where you can plant a tree here, put some high rough here, plug a sandtrap and create another one, move the pin position, etc. Bowling has guidlines that must be followed by USBC so creating a longer and or wider lane would be illegal.

NateNice

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 649
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #2 on: October 10, 2006, 07:34:30 PM »
I think the game is fine.

If I want a challange I'll Sport Bowl.

Bowling balls have changed the game no doubt, but we're not going to go backwards.  You still have to throw it.

Heavier pins?  What's next, longer or thinner lanes?

CoachJim

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1044
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #3 on: October 10, 2006, 08:57:14 PM »
The game needs either an oil free lane that is standard for all competition, or a uniform sanctioned shot which is a doable thing since 90% of all centers are synthetic and have aircondtioning, the shot would have to be adjusted for temperature and humidity and other variables like worn lane surfaces, or wood, and would be determined by the USBC. I think with a little research it could be done.

pin-chaser

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1802
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #4 on: October 10, 2006, 09:48:29 PM »
Bill Taylor spent millions of his own money developing none oil lanes. Nobody interested.

Pro's bowling on heavier pins will further destroy the image of the pro bowlers as there scores will come down even more compared against house hacks.

If I dont throw todays equipment against someone who does I cant win NO MATTER how much better I am. Todays technology is that important.

I know of several bowlers, good bowlers, who quit bowling because of technology and how easy the game became for them. Granted these guys are the exception but even so, the solution(s) for the woe's of bowling  should include these bowlers. We certainly should not be loosing the good ones.

If you dont believe it is bowling balls then drill up a white dot and bowl. If you can average the same then you are truely a great bowler. If you can average within 20 pin you might be a great bowler. (I know there are exceptions to this but I am talking about the masses).

There are so many miss stated facts within this debate (and every other debate on this topic) people simply believe what they read or hear. The bottom line is the greatest, GREATEST bowlers in the world all agree that integrity is a primary culprit. And who are we, the mediocre beleive we understand the issues at hand. In fact, the better you become at this "sport", the more you will realize it. The bottom line is who do we want to be leading the charge in returning bowling to , the best or the masses who dont understand it.

Dont get me wrong this topic is about scoring, but there are many issues that need to be resolved. Integrity is just one issue and until some real studies have been done we dont know the priority of the issues. But without a doubt, integrity is one and let us not forget it. And just because the masses like the scoring pace does not make it right. Period.
--------------------

Bowling Tips and Articles at: www.bowlingknowledge.com
IRC: Internet Relay Chat on Dalnet #striketalk. 24x7x365
Sponsored by: http://bowlerx.com



Chasing pins for 45 years.

BOWL119

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1728
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #5 on: October 10, 2006, 10:11:29 PM »
PINCHASER makes some valid points. But one thing that I have thought about was this: Did bowling ball companies change due to lanes or the way bowlers were now bowling? Change the dynamics of the ball to work for Mark Roth (just using a name) and the way he bowls? Someone must have done a study and saw that putting a weight block kicked off to one side would help Roth shoot higher scores?

I am not saying this is THE reason, but it might have lead to where we are today. And I personally like where we are today. Technology is a great thing. Because of technology, we have alot of the things, cable, sattelite, cars, trucks, campers, better shoes, because of it.
--------------------
T.J.

BOWLING IS FUN NO MATTER WHAT YOU SCORE. BUT A 300 IS ALWAYS NICE.

STRIKE ZONE & PYRO. STAND 15 AND THROW 10 OUT TO 5 AND SMASH THE POCKET. AT LEAST THAT IS THE PLAN OF THE NIGHT...

BrianCRX90

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2486
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #6 on: October 10, 2006, 10:24:22 PM »
Fine, let's all bowl with 5 pound pins...anyone that has a USBC card. Bowl open play or unsanctioned you get your white colored 2 lb 8 ounce pin. Bowl in USBC league you get a 5 lb pin. Watch when bowlers then would be forced to aim high flush. Get it a little wide you get splits, get it a little high you get splits. Less garbage hits, more quality strikes. Now if you average 180, say hello to averaging 160. If you have low ball speed your screwed or if you have a weak strike ball your screwed.

pin-chaser

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1802
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #7 on: October 10, 2006, 10:29:05 PM »
Bowl119,

  The story as I know it (because I quit bowling from 1991 to 200) was that in the early 1990's one bowler established an all time ABC average record by 10 pins. ABC was present to watch and noticed that his ball flared due to abnormal construction. A study was done and Mo Pinel mastered a new technology of flare. Thats the simplistic version. But I believe the details are correct.

  Which came first??? Ball technology... and bowlers are a product of that technology. Also, this time marks the point when bowling balls over powered the lane conditioner. Today ball change the pattern with nearly every shot where as complete styles could be eliminated by lane oil.

   I hope this information is correct.
--------------------

Bowling Tips and Articles at: www.bowlingknowledge.com
IRC: Internet Relay Chat on Dalnet #striketalk. 24x7x365
Sponsored by: http://bowlerx.com



Chasing pins for 45 years.

RealBowler

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 722
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #8 on: October 11, 2006, 09:30:13 AM »
Can somebody please explain what you mean by "restoring integrity"?

I don't really see that there is a problem.  Yes, there is a problem with the way people perceive bowling, and a problem with the dwindling number of bowlers, but what's the deal with the integrity of the sport?

I understand that people get tired of coming on here and reading posts like "heck, anybody that can hit the same mark twice should be able to bowl a 300," or "wow, your first 300....what took you so long?" or "this game is too easy."  

I also understand that this site represents a very small group of people compared to the entire bowling community, and I also understand that any schmuck with an e-mail address can register here and claim to average whatever they want.
--------------------
Haywood

**************************
I don't need a stupid
signature. This is enough.
**************************

BOWL119

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1728
Re: Restoring integrity
« Reply #9 on: October 11, 2006, 11:11:38 AM »
quote:
I also understand that any schmuck with an e-mail address can register here and claim to average whatever they want.
--------------------
Haywood

**************************
I don't need a stupid
signature. This is enough.
**************************


Haywood, But after a few posts, the regular bolwers on here will be able to figure out the this SCHMUCK is just that.
--------------------
T.J.

BOWLING IS FUN NO MATTER WHAT YOU SCORE. BUT A 300 IS ALWAYS NICE.

STRIKE ZONE & PYRO. STAND 15 AND THROW 10 OUT TO 5 AND SMASH THE POCKET. AT LEAST THAT IS THE PLAN OF THE NIGHT...