We've been using both in the shop.  I think energizer is a better overall cleaner, especially if belt marks need to be removed.  We're finding that the foam is better suited to cleaning dull surfaces after the oil is extracted.  I use the foam as more of a secondary applicant after Energizer or a spray nine treatment.
--------------------
-DJ Marshall
...The Twelve In a Row Pro Shop.  AMF Bowie Lanes -- Bowie, MD

The foam seems to get the sticky stuff off fairly well.  i have been using Zapp-It for my normal cleaning and the foam for more difficult little things.

Smash49
--------------------
Smash49

Slick, tacky, wood or synthetic it does not matter your slide is correct with SLSM Designs Bowlers Slide Sock. The Finest Slide Sock on the Planet!!!
www.bowlersslidesock.com
Striking Cat Bowling Pro Shop inside Chisholm Trail Bowling Lanes of Duncan Oklahoma!
www.chisholmtraillanes.com