The No Sweat doesn't really work for me either. I use thumb tape as well, at it would start lifting off around the edges before I even throw my first ball. I would wash my hands with dish washing soap to remove the oils, even alcohol after, and it would still come off. I now use BENZOIN COMPOUND TINCTURE, and it will keep the tape on for the whole night. It would still lift off a little bit around the side edges just a little, but not enough for me to change the tape or cause any release issues.
Now with that problem resolved, I just need to deal with the rest of my sweaty hands. I'll have to go to my local cvs to see if they have those sprays. Sounds promising,
I know it sounds like I'm in denial, but I'm not.