Ok, whatever the cause, it sounds like you're gripping the ball. I bought a 500 count roll of white tape about 3 or 4 years ago because my thumb size would change several times throughout the night. However, after I changed my thumb pitch to 0, I don't need it anymore. Take a look at your thumb, I'll bet it's angled back, or away from your palm. People used to think that reverse would help you get out of the ball easier, but all it really does is make you grip harder throughout the whole swing, and when you're gripping harder, it makes it harder to let the ball go too. Try keeping your thumb straight, and if you find that you aren't able to hang onto the ball without gripping, you most likely have too much reverse pitch in your thumb.