Hey bowler 801,
IMHO, I also use white on the front and back of my thumb, have for years without a problem but "feel" is unique to each individual.
In answer to your question, I have also cut tape smaller than the 3/4 inch (the already smaller piece) or if you can find what was old finger tape (1/2 inch pre-cut) and try that.
Another trick I use and teach is to take another piece of tape and lower
it from your original piece by a good half inch. When we just add another piece of tape over the existing piece, it can snug the top of the hole too much and still leave the bottom loose because the meatier part of our thumb is closer to the top of the thumb hole. By lowering the tape, we create a small taper which contours more to our natural thumb shape. Hope this helps some...
Rick Leong - Ten Pins Pro Shop
Tag Team Coaching - Co-Founder
(Congrats to students Scott Boyle - 2011 Team USA Champion and Mike Fujita Jr - 2010 Collegiate Masters Champion)
"El" Presidente of the Legion