I've only used Magic Carpets. They will last at least one season for me and when I have had to remove one to work out the thumbhole, I have been able to successfully reinsert the old Magic Carpet and continue to bowl. For the price, the durability, and the results, I have never even thought about trying velcro. Plus, you support your local proshop and the inventor who is a bowler by using Magic Carpets and there is even the free samples available for those who want to try the Magic Carpets.
--------------------
I am the Sgt Schultz of bowling.
"I know nothing! I see nothing! NOTHING!"
_________________________________________
New to BR? - Please check this:
BR FAQ