My teams this year in both my leagues are not performing well. We're about 8th place in a 14 team league on Tuesday nights, and about 20th place out of 30ish teams on Saturday night. I average 215 in one league, 228 in the other. The other averages on my teams:
Tuesday: approx. 160, 170, 175, 170
Saturday: approx. 195, 115, 170, 175
In other words, just good enough to not have a ton of handicap, just bad enough to not win games.
I was on a team a few years ago that flat out dominated a second shift league -- everybody on the team averaged between 200 and 230, and we consistently shot well -- at least one person each game was in the 250+ range. I think we won all but two or three games each half and easily won the roll-off (not to mention almost every jackpot every night). That was nice for a change!!