Not sure how much luck you're going to have trying to avoid Royal Pin (assuming from your signature) but you might want to try Hindel or Blue River Bowl in Shelbyville. I bowled the Tuesday night men's league last year at Blue River, and it was a blast each and every week. Great group of guys, very respectful even to a young no-namer like me. Let me know if it interests you.. I was engaged with the manager of Blue River for quite some time.
I've got a spot open here in Muncie on the Wednesday night scratch league if you're wanting to drive the distance. I can't blame you if its not worth the drive, but the spot is available.
I've still got my Sport Bowl name tag in the car. Funny, but sad.