If you requested up to 15lb 5oz and their policy is +- 3 oz, seems like they filled the order properly. It would have been so easy to drill the finger holes just a touch deeper and balance hole to take out another 2 oz, so really your getting awefully upset over 1oz. .4% of the ball weight. Did you even have somebody weight ball. Box labels are not always perfect. It could have been even lighter. Seems like your getting all worked up over something pretty minor. Glad they resolved the problem for you though.