Here's how I view it:
Patrick Allen
10 titles
1 Major
1 POY Award
Over $1,000,000 in career earnings
If he had some catastrophic career ending injury right now (which I certainly hope never happens to anyone), I would put him in the HOF based on the stats above in the timeframe it was done.
If, however, he bowls for another 10 years on tour and bowls subpar and wins no more titles, I would have to say he would not get in because he would not have that consisitency over the longer period of time to be considered with the all time greats in the HOF.
I think that realistically, as long as he bowls around 10 more years on tour (which should happen barring injury), and as long as he gets to 15 titles in that span of 10 years, or one more Major or POY award in that time frame regardless of how many titles he ends up with, he should be a lock for the HOF. I feel that PA is one of the best bowling minds out on tour right now (even though he is quirky on TV). If you ever get to meet him and talk with him, he is very personable and knowlegeable about the game of bowling. I hope he gets in the HOF someday, because as a fellow lefty, I admire a lefty who is very cerebral about the game of bowling and leaves it all out there every time out. Just my .02.
--------------------
MainePBA