I had this happen several times, using the same cleaning/oild extraction method (bucket, hot tap water, and a small shot of APC). I found that the phasing reaction happened frequently when I used dish washing detergent - very thoroughly (e.g. a Shock & Awe, originally a bright light blue and salmon pearl, turned into an almost solid grey/dull orange!)! This did never happen when I used general all-purpose cleaners, though, so I became cautious concerning the cleaner I use for the bucket bath.
However, with frequent use and oil absorption the effect will disappear, or you can sand it away if that's part of your ball cleaning/maintenance regimen.