I believe you have the HP4 line covered well with adding just the Totally Defiant. That would be 3 balls in the hp 4 line, with that said I would look at getting a Deranged instead of the Soul, just so you have that step down ( hp 3 line) when needed. The Wrecker I believe will be a good piece as well, unless you can find a Rising Star, then I would vote for that ball, and it is stronger than you might think, it's not for light oil,IMO. I also might suggest a entry line ball if you need for dryer conditions.

I think you have the upper end covered really well with the Defiant and Critical Theory.  Don't change anything with those.

I would definitely look to get 1 mid and 1 entry level ball.  Based on your stats, I could see you going with a Disturbed or Deranged as your mid level ball.  Both have great core/cover matches and would give you versatility on your medium patterns.  It would just depend if you want something that is going to go longer and be stronger in back (Deranged) or if you want more of an even arcing piece that reads slightly earlier (Disturbed).

On the entry side, definitely go with the Wrecker.  That ball is an excellent choice for your medium-light patterns.   One of my teammates used the Wrecker in the second half of the season once we saw lighter volumes, and that ball proved itself very quickly as a must have. 

If you can find a Rising Star as Metal_rules mentioned, get it over the Wrecker.  That ball was tough to beat.  Only reason I don't have mine anymore is because I jumped up from 15 to 16lbs and ended up with a Frantic instead.  I loved wheeling the Rising Star on light volume patterns, and that ball had more than enough recovery.

I am really surprised to hear that your Rising Star did not work for you. This has been my go to ball for a while. I am sure that you are aware sometimes you may need to adjust the cover to get the reaction that you are looking for, I did. The Disturbed is just flat out outstanding, it has a nice smooth roll with a strong continuous arch, hits hard. If you are looking at another solid,this is the ball for you. I had a Defiant, and I didn't like it until I changed the cover. But I prefer the Disturbed over the Defiant, so I sold my Defiant. I also understand the new releases are hard to make a choice without seeing what they do. If you are not sure, then wait for just a bit until you can see them in person or until there are more videos, but the bowlers in the videos never throw the ball exactly like I do, so they are not as accurate as I would like. As for Rotos mid level balls, they are second to none. I  have had most of my honor scores with mid level balls, the most recent with my Rising Star and Disturbed. The most important factor is obviously getting the correct layout and surface, and using the right ball that matches up with that pattern, with your style. I have the utmost confidence of the person I see for my layouts and ball suggestions, and that is my suggestion, to discuss it with your pro shop if you are unsure on what to get. Don't be in a rush, take your time and do your research, then you will be confident in your selections. As for the Soul, I don't currently have one, but from what I have seen, its a great ball. So if you really want it, get one - but check out all of your options first, you might fill a need with another ball. Either way you cant go wrong with any ROTO GRIP ball.

Thank guys for all the responses. I will be patient in making my choices, i still have a month before our fall leagues start. I think i have narrowed my choices to either the disturbed and the deranged, more than likely a totally defiant, and the wrecker. Got some good news i think i might get my rising star back from by uncle, he likes storm better. The good we have the same spec when in comes to drill so no changes have to be made. Just curious in what i should do to the cover to match up well for me.

Thanks

tloy,

Thanks for that information about the defiant soul. I think that ball is an exceptional pieces of equipment that would give alot of success. I am still thinking of getting both the disturber and the deranged, cause many reviews say they compliment each other very well. What do u think about the Totally defiant and how do entry balls work for you, like the wrecker and the rising star.

thanks