Bill,
My only thing against the Defiants is they're too rolly and too early. I suspect it's one of those balls with particles that are unadvertised. They seem to take either a lot of oil or a lot of ball speed to use them properly. It's so easy to leave a lot of flat 10 pins, when you're lucky, worse when you're not lucky.
I've never seen either the solid or the pearl Defiant have a strong backend or even close to it. I've seen both Mutants and Theorys have a fairly strong backend, even with a non-polished surface.
To my eye, the Mutants had a stronger backend, more like the Virtual Gravity. My Theory was much like that with dulll and polished surfaces and with 2 different drillings. That's why I felt the Theory and potentially the Critical Theory would be closer to the Mutants.
While I suspect the Critical can fill this dual roll, I can't guarantee it.