I have to admit I seen the BJI rating and also thought it was a typo but their reviewer is a pretty credible source so maybe that is what they are seeing.
I have had mine about a month now and it is starting to grow on me more and more. Right now out of the box, I have it moving slightly more than my Rocket Ship. I was using as a ball down from my Snap Lock when it started to ping tens's.
I have the Hustle P/R/O and it is longer but it also comes factory shined. I balled down from the Wreck It to the P/R/O and had to move about 6 boards right the other night in league. I also need to hit the P/R/O with my 3000 pad to knock the skid/flip Storm factory shine of it.
I do not know if the Wreck It ranks up there with the Sinister or Crux which were balls that BJI gave 58 and 58.5 hook ratings to but it is definitely stronger than the Rocket Ship(in my opinion) which is a 54 or 55 I believe.