Without seeing the Asylum in action but knowing it's in the HP3 line, it should be stronger overall than the Frantic.  The closer comparison will most likely be the Asylum vs the Hy-Road or the IQ Tour Fusion (if and when it comes out stateside).

Comparing the Hy-Road and Frantic, the Frantic is weaker overall due to the different symmetrical core between the 2 balls.  Both use the same hybrid cover.

This would still be a comparison I'd love to see once the Asylum comes out. I agree with the rest that the Asylum will definitely be for heavier oil than the Frantic even if they were both at the same finish and yeah the Hyroad will likely be a closer comparison but somebody needs to make this comparo happen!